1957 - Ned Oldham
1958 - George Fritzinger
1959 - Joe Bellino
1960 - Joe Bellino
1961 - Greg Mather
1962 - Roger Staubach
1963 - Roger Staubach
1964 - Roger Staubach
1965 - Fred Mousally
1966 - Don Downing
1967 - John Cartwright
1968 - Michael Lettieri
1969 - Daniel Pike
1970 - John 'Mike' McNallen
1971 - Glen Nardi
1972 - Cleveland Cooper
1973 - Albert Calland III
1974 - Chester Moeller
1975 - Chester Moeller
1976 - Jeffrey Sapp
1977 - Joseph Gattuso
1978 - Philip McConkey
1979 - Charlie Thornton
1980 - Frank McCallister
1981 - Eddie Meyers
1982 - Andy Ponseigo
1983 - Napoleon McCallum
1984 - Chris Weiler
1985 - Napoleon McCallum
1986 - Vincent McBeth
1987 - Matthew Felt
1988 - Troy Holland
1989 - David Lowe
1990 - Alton Grizzard
1991 - Jason Van Matre
1992 - Bob Kubeski
1993 - Javier Zuluaga
1994 - Shane Halloran
1995 - Sean Andrews
1996 - Clint Bruce
1997 - Chris McCoy
1988 - Jason Snider
1999 - Terrence Anderson
2000 - Chris Lepore
2001 - Brian Madden
2002 - Craig Candeto
2003 - Craig Candeto
2004 - Josh Smith
2005 - Lamar Owens
2006 - David Mahoney
2007 - Reggie Campbell
2008 - Shun White
2009 - Ross Pospisil
2010 - Ricky Dobbs
2011 - Jabaree Tuani
2012 - Keegan Wetzel
2013 - Keenan Reynolds
2014 - Keenan Reynolds
2015 - Keenan Reynolds
2016 - Will Worth
2017 - D.J. Palmore
2018 -Sean Williams
2019- Malcolm Perry
2020- not presented
2021- Diego Fagot
2022- John Marshall
2023- Colin Ramos
2024- Colin Ramos